Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Natural immunity or COVID-19 vaccine mandates? Some study somewhere proves your point, by Tom Wrobleski

Natural immunity or COVID-19 vaccine mandates? Some study somewhere proves your point, by Tom Wrobleski

  • 3

No matter where you stand in the debate over COVID-19 vaccines, there’s a study that proves your point and gives you ammunition against the other side of the argument.

It’s no wonder people are confused. Or angry. Or resistant. Or are merely asking whether everybody in the country really needs to be vaccinated and whether it’s fair to exclude from schools, workplaces and restaurants those who aren’t vaccinated.

An Israeli study said that those who had COVID and recovered from it have considerably more protection from the Delta variant than that offered by the Pfizer vaccine.

The study said that’s the way the immune system works: Having suffered the virus, it’s on guard should it confront the virus again. The body remembers the battle and is ready to engage again.

Just to cover the bases here: Nobody is suggesting that you go out and get infected on purpose so you can gain natural immunity. And, yes, the experts say that the vaccines offer stout protection from serious infection and hospitalization for many.

But with natural immunity in mind, it’s fair to ask whether those who’ve had COVID-19 definitely need to be vaccinated and whether they should automatically be excluded from life if they’re not.

And it begs the question as to why natural immunity is hardly being talked about as an anti-pandemic strategy.

Natural immunity is well-established science. Shouldn’t it at least be part of the conversation, especially when a number of fully vaccinated people are getting infected?

Which brings us to an August report from Bloomberg News about the growing concern that vaccinated people may be more susceptible to COVID-19 than originally thought.

Which, on the one hand, buoys those who are opposed to vaccine mandates. Why get the vaccine if it may not work?

But it also strengthens the hand of those who think we should continue to mask up and socially distance. Because we just don’t know how much we can rely on the vaccine.

Confused yet?

And there are also reports that the effectiveness of the vaccines wanes over time. Pointing to research done in the United Kingdom, Reuters reported that vaccine protection may begin to fade within six months.

Which, yes, gives ammunition to those who are calling for booster shots to be given. But it also stiffens the spines of those who thought that getting the vaccine was all that would be required of them.

A study from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention the other day said that 83% of Americans age 16 and older have some kind of immunity from COVID-19 either through prior infection or because they’ve been vaccinated.

The study said that a lot more people likely had been infected than initially thought because they had mild cases or no symptoms and were never tested. They never made it into the infection databases.

Remember back in the early days of the pandemic, when the experts said that we’d be in pretty good shape with 80% immunity, that we’d reach a level of herd protection? Yeah, I remember those days too.

And just let me say: I’m fully vaccinated. I’m not an anti-vaxxer.

If you’re vaccinated and want to get a booster shot, I won’t judge you.

And I won’t look at you funny if you’re not vaccinated. Or if you feel that vaccination is enough and you shouldn’t be compelled to get booster shots.

But nothing about the COVID-19 is plain and simple. There are experts lined up on all sides. There are studies galore.

We’ve been told to “follow the science.” Who knew that the science would go down so many different paths?

Oh, and have you heard of the Mu variant yet?

You will.

Tom Wrobleski wrote this for the Staten Island Advance, N.Y.

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Many reactions to COVID-19 can be explained by one simple concept: intertemporal substitution. Its awkward name notwithstanding, the idea helps to make sense of many behaviors that otherwise might appear irrational. At the most basic level, intertemporal substitution means shifting an action or event to a more appropriate or advantageous time. A classic example from economics is that people ...

If it's a year ending in a number, then federal tax policy is again on the table. This year differs from the recent norm, however: The debate in Washington is over raising taxes — more specifically, by how much. Democratic tax proposals, which are aimed at funding a budget bill expected to cost hundreds of billions of dollars per year, are still in flux, with formal plans expected to be made ...

The Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center recently released a report saying that 61% of U.S. households had paid no federal income tax in 2020, up from 44% in 2019, as the pandemic led to high unemployment and loss of income. Although the number will likely revert to the mid-40% range over time, now is probably a good time to have a discussion about what the right percentage of people paying taxes ...

In the days before COVID-19, I’d often get frustrated by the response that doctors would give when I turned up at their clinics with some infection or other: “It’s just a virus,” they’d say. As someone who’s long been fascinated by the detective work that goes into tracing the origins and history of infections, the answer always seemed too perfunctory. Which virus was it? Where and when did ...

In the period leading up to the Constitution’s bicentennial, the late constitutional scholar Walter Berns was asked to give an address on the Constitution in a Latin American country. After delivering his remarks, a clearly agitated man directed a question to the event’s sponsors: “Why,” he asked, “was this American giving a lecture to us? After all, our country has had numerous constitutions, ...

The best local coverage, unlimited

Sign up for a digital subscription to The Press of Atlantic City now and take advantage of a great offer.


Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News