Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Fantastical rhetoric from Gavin Newsom and Kamala Harris in recall political theater

Fantastical rhetoric from Gavin Newsom and Kamala Harris in recall political theater

  • 0

So, at this point, we’ve clearly reached peak political fantasyland.

I know, I know. That probably wasn’t the takeaway Democratic Party activists and union leaders had hoped to deliver with Wednesday’s bit of political theater, starring Vice President Kamala Harris returning to the San Francisco Bay Area to rhetorically rescue her longtime frenemy Gov. Gavin Newsom.

But what can I say? I’m a realist.

I’m not sure how else to think of the many gushing remarks about the enviable strength of California’s post-pandemic economy, and its policies that ensure living wages and safe working conditions. Or, as Harris insisted, that “Gavin has always understood that if you want to lift up America, you’ve got to lift up working people.”

It was surely a coincidence that the vice president’s words sounded like those of President Biden, who, from the White House, touted “worker power” as essential to “building our economy back better than before.”

“Instead of workers competing with each other for the jobs that are scarce,” Biden said proudly, “everybody’s mad at me because now — guess what — employers are competing to attract workers, having to raise pay.”

Let’s get real for moment, shall we? Because things aren’t that great for everyone.

Despite Democrats’ many valiant policy efforts — from implementing paid family leave to the child tax credit — we’re still in real danger of building back a post-pandemic economy that’s as uneven and unfair as it always has been to people of color at the bottom of the income scale.

Not that most Californians believe Republicans, with their shortsighted, pull-yourself-up-by-the-bootstraps ideology, are better equipped to address these issues. After all, it wasn’t Newsom whom homeless people angrily chased out of Venice on Wednesday; it was one of his would-be replacements, conservative talk show host Larry Elder.

But assuming Newsom prevails in this week’s recall election, it remains to be seen what he can do for the many working class people — particularly Latino and Black people — who are struggling to make ends meet and, in some cases, are on the verge of eviction.

Longtime civil rights leader and labor activist Rev. James Lawson Jr. was sounding the alarm about this in a conversation we had way back in July, just a few days after the UCLA Labor Center was renamed in his honor.

He calls it “plantation capitalism.”

Despite my optimism, Lawson wasn’t entirely convinced of what we’ve all been hearing for months: namely that workers, across the board, are regaining power over employers. That the post-pandemic labor shortage is simply a function of picky Americans who are reassessing what conditions and what pay they find acceptable to go to back to work.

For sure, help wanted signs are everywhere, and employers large and small are desperate to fill open positions.

Hiring bonuses no longer even seem to do the trick. Now it’s all about the incentives. Target, for example, is offering to pay college tuition. Applebee’s is offering free food. And Amazon, ever inventive, is promoting that people who apply to be delivery drivers won’t be screened for cannabis.

“I appreciate the moment in which we live, the changes that have begun,” Lawson told me. “But I see that the length of the changes that must happen being longer in the future.”

He cited the more complicated experiences for workers of color, particularly Black women. Indeed, women, in general, have borne the brunt of the pandemic economically.

“Plantation capitalism says that working people don’t need to be treated as people,” Lawson said. “They are more of a commodity and property than they are human.”

Now data indicate he might be right.

According to the latest report from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the unemployment rate for Black Americans jumped from 8.2% in July to 8.8% in August. The reason is that while more Black people were working in August than July, the number looking for jobs was even higher.

Moreover, the unemployment rate for the other groups dropped in August. The overall rate was 5.2%, and for white Americans 4.5%.

William Spriggs, chief economist for the AFL-CIO and an economics professor at Howard University, questioned how desperate employers really are to find workers when so many Black Americans can’t find work.

It’s why the Brookings Institution warned this month that the hot, post-pandemic labor market alone won’t reverse longstanding racial disparities in the jobless rate.

As Spriggs put it to multiple journalists, it’s “the self-evident discrimination in the labor market revealing itself.”

There also are the anecdotal stories.

On a recent day, I listened to two Black women talk about the racial discrimination, harassment and retaliation they had allegedly experienced, spelled out in a pair of lawsuits filed against their former employer, a hotel.

“People who are Black have had to go through these things,” April Blackwell said, speaking to a small crowd of supporters from the back of a flatbed truck parked in the shadow of the hotel as the sun began to set over Sunset Boulevard.

Her words echoed those of Thommi Gross.

“Being who I am on the outside — my skin tone — being a woman, we’re not believed,” she said. “We’re working twice as hard for less pay and we are shown that we are not as valuable. So it’s really frustrating. It’s disheartening. It’s dehumanizing.”

No one at the hotel returned my request for a comment.

This was the latest such demonstration organized by Unite Here Local 11, which has been calling for a boycott ever since hundreds of the hotel’s employees complained they were laid off without insurance or severance, just as COVID-19 cases were exploding last year.

Both Gross and Blackwell lamented that their claims will be handled in private arbitration, rather than in state court where they were initially filed. It’s a fate that, despite legislative changes and the #MeToo movement, continues to disproportionately affect women and workers of color.

It’s a reminder of just how much about the labor market is more complicated for our people.

If Newsom survives the recall election — and polls increasingly indicate that he will — his challenge will be to live up to the praise that Harris bestowed upon him.

“I want Black women to be valued in the workplace,” Gross said. “I want any employee who feels like they’re not in a safe space. That they can come to their employer, and they get the support and the protection they need.”

That’s your dose of reality for today.

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Many reactions to COVID-19 can be explained by one simple concept: intertemporal substitution. Its awkward name notwithstanding, the idea helps to make sense of many behaviors that otherwise might appear irrational. At the most basic level, intertemporal substitution means shifting an action or event to a more appropriate or advantageous time. A classic example from economics is that people ...

Seeing the pictures of damage from the magnitude 7.2 earthquake in Haiti makes me think once again about what California will be like after our next big urban earthquake. Because we have, and mostly enforce, well-designed “life safety” building codes, we will be able to crawl out alive from any building built to those modern standards, and the death toll will be comparatively small. But ...

In the days before COVID-19, I’d often get frustrated by the response that doctors would give when I turned up at their clinics with some infection or other: “It’s just a virus,” they’d say. As someone who’s long been fascinated by the detective work that goes into tracing the origins and history of infections, the answer always seemed too perfunctory. Which virus was it? Where and when did ...

Glenn Youngkin wants to talk about qualified immunity. Not many people know what it is — and even people who think they do often misunderstand it — but Youngkin, the Republican candidate for governor of Virginia, says it’s one of the top reasons to vote for him. Terry MacAuliffe, the Democratic candidate, wants to abolish qualified immunity for police officers. Youngkin says that would expose ...

If it's a year ending in a number, then federal tax policy is again on the table. This year differs from the recent norm, however: The debate in Washington is over raising taxes — more specifically, by how much. Democratic tax proposals, which are aimed at funding a budget bill expected to cost hundreds of billions of dollars per year, are still in flux, with formal plans expected to be made ...

The best local coverage, unlimited

Sign up for a digital subscription to The Press of Atlantic City now and take advantage of a great offer.


Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News